51 Fair St, Nantucket, MA 02554
$18,000/mo · For rent
- 4 bedrooms
- 3.5 bathrooms
- 1,566 sq ft
- Apartment
- MLS #73468651
Charming Victorian-style home available for the season on the tree-lined portion of Fair Street in Nantucket’s historic district, just moments from Main Street shops, restaurants, and town amenities. This beautifully restored home has been completely renovated and blends classic Nantucket character with all-new interiors and furnishings throughout, inside and out.The thoughtfully expanded layout includes a new kitchen, laundry, and pantry, along with brand-new HVAC and mechanical systems, offering modern comfort while preserving historic charm. A welcoming front porch and enclosed rear patio provide ideal spaces for relaxing and entertaining, while the landscaped yard offers privacy in town.The interior features four bedrooms, three and one-half baths, and comfortable living areas with custom built-ins, a bright kitchen, and a wood-burning fireplace. Off-street parking adds convenience. A rare opportunity to enjoy turnkey seasonal living in one of Nantucket’s most desirable and wal
About this address
51 Fair St is a 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath rental in Nantucket, MA 02554 with 1,566 square feet, asking $18,000 a month. It has been on our site since July 15, 2026.
The median asking rent among the 12 other 4-bedroom rentals in Nantucket is $17,250 a month. This one asks about 4% more.
At 1,566 square feet, it is smaller than 92% of the 12 other 4-bedroom rentals in Nantucket with a stated size.
This home is assessed at $3,092,700 for fiscal year 2026. The assessor lists a lot of 0.07 acres.
It scores 92 out of 100 for walkability, from how close everyday places are.
The closest bus stop is West Dover Street/Orange Street (NRTA routes Miacomet Loop, Mid Island Loop), about 0.1 miles away.
The closest public schools by level are Nantucket Elementary (0.7 miles), Cyrus Peirce (0.4 miles) and Nantucket High (0.4 miles). The district decides which school serves an address.
Listing information from MLS Property Information Network (MLS PIN), MLS #73468651, deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Prices are compared with other homes listed on this site today. Trains and buses come from the transit agencies’ published schedules and schools from the National Center for Education Statistics. Distances are straight-line. Assessed values and past sales are public records from municipal assessors, published by MassGIS. An assessed value is set for taxation and may differ from market value.
More homes for rent in Nantucket
- 77 Sparks Avenue, Nantucket — $18,000/mo · 6 bd, 4 ba
- 75 Baxter Road, Nantucket — $18,000/mo · 3 bd, 2 ba
- 7 North Liberty, Nantucket — $17,250/mo · 4 bd, 3.5 ba
- 7 N Liberty #_, Nantucket — $17,250/mo · 4 bd, 3.5 ba
- 86 Centre Street, Nantucket — $18,824/mo · 4 bd, 4.5 ba
- 49 Pine Street, Nantucket — $19,500/mo · 6 bd, 5.5 ba
- 63 Monomoy Rd #_, Nantucket — $16,500/mo · 4 bd, 2.5 ba
- 8 Maine Avenue, Nantucket — $20,000/mo · 3 bd, 2 ba
See all Nantucket homes for sale and rent, every home in Nantucket by street, or browse every rental and neighborhood guides with Benjamin Realty.
To ask about this home or book a tour, call Benjamin Realty at (617) 734-5050 or email [email protected].